Skip to main content

Best cookies in Tioga.

Cookies for Every Craving
Freshly Baked Cookies

Freshly Baked Cookies

Cookies make a sweet finish to a deli sandwich, cheesesteak, wrap, or slice of pizza. Pair a cookie with breakfast or enjoy one as an afternoon treat with a bagel and a drink. Their familiar flavors are easy to share, making cookies a welcome choice for family meals, casual lunches, and a little something sweet after your favorite American comfort food.
Delivery and Pickup Made Easy

Delivery and Pickup Made Easy

Enjoy cookies at home or pick them up alongside sandwiches, subs, cheesesteaks, wraps, pizza, and breakfast favorites. Choose delivery when you want an easy meal brought to your door, or place a pickup order for a convenient stop on your way through Newberry. Add cookies to your order for a simple dessert to share with family or enjoy on your own.

Our location

Map showing the location of Dave's New York Deli on 12921 SW 1st road Tioga Town in Newberry
Loading today's hours...